

If you have a theme or detail request, they can accommodate it.

Magnolia Bakery is great for control freaks or people who want to exercise wedding-cake-level-control over the design process of their cake. Here, you can finesse every detail down to the bordering and piping of their equally delicious birthday cakes. Known for their insanely delicious old fashion Banana Pudding (something on every NYC foodie’s bucket list), the bakery also makes excellent cupcakes and cakes. Magnolia Bakery is perhaps the most “classic”, old time-y New York City bakery. || Image: Magnolia Bakery Magnolia Bakery (A New York Classic Known For Timeless Elegance)

Seasonal Pumpkin Spice Cake with sugared berries at Magnolia Bakery. (Somewhat related: Those who like baking should also check out Tosi’s new cookbook, All About Cake, which is a great gift to give alongside one of her actual cakes.)
#Capsy cake nyc how to
Ultimately, Milk Bar’s confetti cakes are so popular that Milk Bar now offers classes on how to make them yourself.Īlso, gluten intolerant folks take note: Milk Bar now offers gluten-free versions of the confetti cake, so more people can participate in the magic of the best birthday cake in NYC. They also have several locations around the city, so the cakes are easy to get and transport. As an extension of the Momofuku franchise, they now ship nationally, but the original bakery is based in NYC.

Every New Yorker who lives here for long enough eventually either a) buys this cake for someone else on their birthday or b) has had someone else buy this cake for them on their birthday.Ĭhristina Tosi’s Milk Bar empire, moreover, is no joke. Milk Bar’s iconic confetti birthday cake is probably the most famous and recognizable cake in the entire city. || Image: Milk Bar Milk Bar (For Iconic Confetti Birthday Cake) *** Milk Bar’s Confetti Birthday Cake is hands down the most popular birthday cake in NYC. There’s something for every taste, style, and affinity here. Ultimately, whether you’re shopping for a kid or just a kid at heart, below are the best places to get cool, delicious birthday cakes in New York City. ( Especially if you are a foodie.)Īnd doesn’t everyone love a good birthday cake? (Answer: yes!) And don’t we all love to Instagram a beautiful, whimsical birthday cake, especially when it’s ours? ( Yes, we definitely do.) For a certain class of working young professionals in NYC, getting a cool birthday cake is a rite of passage. Moreover, many adults in New York City now look forward to ordering fancy birthday cakes just as much as having a nice meal on their birthday. Otherwise, why bother? (Thanks for that, Great British Bake-Off and Holiday Baking Championship…) Interest in clever birthday cake design has recently been stirred by the increasing public interest in televised baking competitions, which have dominated streaming services and prime-time television in recent years.Īs a result, even the average consumer now expects even casual birthday cakes to deliver on flavor, presentation, and originality. This is particularly true in the realm of birthday cakes, which are highly visible and one of the most whimsical aspects of bakery operation. More importantly, New York City has no shortage of excellent bakeries.Īnd with the advent of Instagram, it seems like even the previously unknown Big Apple bakeries are stepping up their cake game. Want to experience one of the best birthday cakes in NYC? As a food critic who’s ordered countless top-notch birthday cakes in the city over the last decade, I can assure you there’s a wide variety to choose from.
